Paper Conservation: An Expert's
Advice
Patricia Morris, a nationally-recognized
paper expert and conservator residing in Santa Fe provides
some advice:
The history of paper goes back to the Chinese
emperor, Ho Ti, whose eunuch, Ts'ai Lun may have invented, sponsored,
and/or patronized the advent of papermaking in 105 AD. These
first papers were made from pulverized cloth scraps, tree bark,
hemp waste, and old fish nets, suspending these fibers in water,
then matting them into crude sheets of paper. These papermaking
techniques reached Japan in 610 AD to be developed and perfected
over the centuries into a fine and delicate art. The craft of
making paper had spread to Baghdad by 793, Spain by 1151, Italy
by 1276, and finally reached England in 1494. The first American
paper was produced by William Rittenhouse near Germantown, Pennsylvania,
in 1690.
The Challenge of Conservation
Effective conservation of works on paper presents an increasingly
serious problem, both for private collectors and responsible
institutions the world over. Millions of artworks on paper,
books, manuscripts, maps, prints and photographs are literally
crumbling into pieces every day. Possibly because the existence
of paper has been taken so much for granted, the necessity
for care and conservation has been largely ignored.
Preserving archival paper materials is difficult;
however, the life expectancy of an artifact can be extended by
understanding and intelligently dealing with the harmful internal
and external factors.
"Enemies" of paper
Misinformed, careless people, though possibly well-intentioned,
cause considerable damage. Improper handling results in stains,
fingerprints and tears; improvised bookmarks leave indelible
impressions on pages. A basic principle of paper conservation
is the concept of "reversibility," i.e., nothing
should be done to an artifact that cannot be undone at a
later time. For this reason, pressure-sensitive tapes (eg,
Scotch and masking) should never be used to mend a tear.
They leave stains that bleed through the paper, never to
be completely removed. "Elmer's" type glues become
difficult, if not impossible, to remove. Mounting or lamination
with a non-archival adhesive will not only eventually cause
damage, but is extremely hard to undo.
Acid, possibly the worst of the "enemies," causes
damage through simple contact between a paper artifact and
a non-archival housing. Improper storage in acidic file folders,
slipcases for books, boxes, and portfolios made of cardboard,
and poor quality matts, will cause rapid damage because acid
in the wood pulp of these materials will migrate into a paper
artifact. For example, when wood has been used in framing,
to back works on paper, the acid migration is clearly visible
in the pattern of the wood grain and knots transferred to the
paper. Acid may also be inherent in the original components
of the artifact. Impoverished artists, later to become famous,
used poor quality paper with a high wood-pulp content, that
became brittle and darkened with time. Iron gall inks become
acid and will affect surrounding paper fibers, eating through
the paper. Sulfur dioxide from polluted air reacts with absorbed
airborne water to make sulfuric acid, which stains and weakens
paper, bleaches dyes, and decomposes leather.
Environmental factors speed deterioration as
well. Light (especially sunlight and fluorescent) will
fade media such as watercolors, pastels and inks, and may darken
papers with a high wood-pulp content. Decay increases as high
light levels combine with high humidity. A certain amount of
moisture is needed to sustain flexibility in paper and leather
fibers, and to maintain strength in adhesives, but too little
moisture will cause fibers and adhesives to weaken and break,
so a sensitive balance must be maintained. Fluctuations in humidity
cause fibers to expand and contract as they first absorb water,
then dehydrate; this movement may lead to cracking and flaking
of fragile media.
High levels of heat in combination with moisture
and the accessibility of cellulose or adhesive as a food source
will encourage mold growth. Mold, or mildew, starts as a powdery
colony of spores, easily brushed or vacuumed off, but as growth
continues and the mold digests fibers and adhesives, permanent
stains will develop in the host material. Leather will rot, and
paper suffers first from surface erosion and finally turns to
a pulpy mess. "Foxing" (small brown spots seen on many
papers) may be the result of a chemical interaction between metal
impurities left in the paper during manufacture or organic acids
released by mold. Insects and rodents are also
attracted to warmth and food. Cockroaches, silverfish, termites,
book lice, bookworms (larvae of beetles), and moths all enjoy
consuming paper, leather and adhesives. Nor does the rodent family
respect archival materials--they will greedily utilize paper
for food and nesting. Preventive Medicine
If the collector, curator, gallery and framer are aware of the
dangers to valuable works on paper, careful maintenance may prevent
many future conservation problems.
Cautious handling, proper housing, and an appropriate
environment are critically important. Artifacts should be stored
only in acid-free materials. Book boxes made from archival quality
substances can protect rare books from chemical contamination
and physical damage. Manuscripts, enclosed in acid-free envelopes
or file folders, should be organized in flat document boxes.
News clippings, generally highly acidic, should be interleaved
with acid-free tissue or glassine paper and stored separately
from better-quality, less-acidic papers. Unframed art on paper
and photographs should be stored flat and individually protected
by acid-free folders or matts, with glassine slip sheets, in
archival boxes or metal filing drawers. Framed paper materials
should be checked for poor quality matts and contact with acidic
(wood/cardboard) backings; and they should be "sealed" with
a dust sheet of paper at the back to help prevent damage by the
environment, insects and dust.
Because acidity is such a problem with paper,
any extremely rare or valuable artifact which is significantly
deteriorated may be "deacidified." In this procedure,
the paper is treated with a water or alcohol-based solution that
neutralizes acidity as it develops. These methods are time-consuming
and expensive, and should be carried out by a trained conservator.
Controlling the physical environment will also
extend the longevity of paper materials. Sunlight should never
fall directly on any work on paper, book or photograph. Fluorescent
tubes can be covered with plastic sleeves, which absorb damaging
ultraviolet light. Paper is most effectively preserved at temperatures
between 60 and 70 degrees Fahrenheit, with the humidity between
50 and 60 percent. Although paper may be safely stored at as
low as 30 percent humidity, leather and parchment will become
desiccated and hard. Compromise with these ideals is obviously
necessary in many cases. Mold or mildew should not develop if
the temperature is kept below 75 degrees F and the relative humidity
below 60 percent. If mold spores are noticed, a light brushing
or careful vacuuming will remove the growth. The artifact should
be aired in a clean, dry room and then be checked periodically
for any recurrence. Cleanliness and regular inspection will keep
insects and rodents under control.
A competent conservator can repair works on
paper and reduce the visual effects of some damage. He or she
can also help to preserve an artifact by chemical treatment,
but the artifact cannot be made "just like new," once
tears, stains, bleaching, or acidic deterioration have occurred.
A preventive philosophy is far less costly, both in terms of
expense and of sustaining the integrity of the art or artifact,
than calling for help after it is too late and the damage is
done.
Prints: Innovative Techniques
Richard Levy, art collector and
owner of Richard
Levy Gallery Albuquerque,
New Mexico
I recently spent a few days in New York City
at the International Fine Print Dealers Association Print Show.
Most people think of prints as traditional etchings, engravings
and lithographs. Times have changed. Walking around the show
I saw new interesting combinations of seemingly incompatible
processes; etchings with hand coloring and silk-screen, waterless
lithographs printed over photographs. There were three-dimensional
prints. A large (probably four feet square) Elizabeth Murray
lithograph was a maze of shapes and colors that stood out a foot
from the wall like freeway interchanges. Several prints by New
York artist Lesley Dill had cut pieces of paper hanging from
threads, one in the shape of hands, and another with different
shapes that together looked like a necklace. Other Lesley Dill
prints were dresses, standing out from the wall or a paper figure
in a shadow box frame with text printed on it. James Drake waterless
lithographs had python skin on each print. A Red Grooms print
in a frame had a tab that caused lithographic hula girls to wiggle
back and forth. Another Red Grooms was a dimensional lithographic
scene, like his room installations, but smaller. A Christo lithograph
of a little red wagon showed the contents of the wagon wrapped
in real cloth and tied down with a real piece of rope. A huge
embossed print by Richard Serra looked as if it had been printed
with road tar. Steven Sorman painted on his prints, creating
an edition with variations in which every print is different.
All of these prints look as if they could be
unique, but all of them are part of an edition. The publisher
is able to spread the cost of producing the edition over many
prints. At the same time the artist is offered a new and different
challenge and allowed to create an affordable interesting edition
that doesn't look like what most people think of as a print.
Not all prints are on paper anymore. Lorna
Simpson printed a whole edition on felt. Her photographs of wigs
would have been beautiful printed on paper, but are more successful
on textured felt. The fuzzy, hairy felt feels more like a wig
than a print on paper ever could.
There was, of course, the usual array of traditional
lithographs, woodcuts, wood engravings, etchings and engravings
from earlier in this century and before. The bright large lithographs
of David Salle, James Rosenquist, Joan Mitchell and Roy Lichtenstein
are still in evidence. Contemporary prints in every size and
shape were beautifully printed and presented. The range and quality
of what is available is a result of the growing number of accomplished
printers who use the available technology in new creative ways
to collaborate with an artist. This widespread talent and experimentation
made for a lively and innovative Print Show this year. An array
of prints is available for every taste and at every price.
Next time you're in a gallery or museum, look
closely at the prints. You might be surprised at what you see.
Photography and Paper
|